Past Reviews

Off Broadway Reviews

Heathers: The Musical

Theatre Review by Howard Miller - July 10, 2025


Elizabeth Teeter, McKenzie Kurtz, and Olivia Hardy
Photo by Evan Zimmerman for MurphyMade
It's a raucous and thoroughly smashing homecoming for the old Westerberg High School gang as the nerds, jocks, clueless staff, and a trio of very mean girls gather for a top-notch revival of Heathers: The Musical opening tonight at what was its original New York home in 2014, New World Stages.

The real world, not to mention the lives of high school students, has changed in so many ways in the past tumultuous decade, yet Heathers has managed to remain as fresh and as crunchy as a newly opened bag of corn nuts. Much of its spot-on success owes thanks both to the sure hand of director Andy Fickman (who has led multiple productions of the show in the UK and by now has polished it to a sheen), and to Kevin Murphy and Laurence O'Keefe's catchy score, clever lyrics, and smartly written book that manages to balance its dark humor roots and potentially disturbing plot elements with sheer entertainment.

Heathers, which is based on (but not lashed to) Daniel Waters' screenplay for the 1988 movie of the same name, is a show that its creators have tinkered with several times since its original production. And it's all been for the good. Tip too far in one direction, and you wind up with a too-genial update of Grease. Head too far in the other direction, and you wind up with the creepiness of Carrie. In a world that is replete with sad, sad stories of school violence, relentless bullying, the dark side of peer pressure, sexual abuse, and teen suicide, Heathers somehow manages to touch on all of these without ever dragging the audience into the abyss.

Meet the title characters, a trio of Heathers whose scathing glare and biting remarks could shrivel the hide of the Wicked Witch of the West, not to mention anyone on their lengthy list of losers and rejects. At center is Heather Chandler (McKenzie Kurtz), she of the withering look and acid tongue, the keeper of the keys to thumbs up survival or thumbs down misery for all who dare cross her path. She can generally be seen sandwiched between her two acolytes, Heather McNamara (Elizabeth Teeter) and Heather Duke (Olivia Hardy), as they terrorize the most vulnerable among their classmates.


Casey Likes and Lorna Courtney
Photo by Evan Zimmerman for MurphyMade
Fortunately, we have someone to guide us through the dangerous halls of Westerberg High, one Veronica Sawyer (Lorna Courtney, a Tony nominee for her performance as Juliet in the musical & Juliet). All Veronica wants is to survive her senior year. In order to do so, the otherwise affable teen comes up with a bribery scheme she hopes will get her in good with the Heathers. That would be her uncanny gift at forgery, from hall passes to grade changes to notes from parents. It's a talent that proves to be good enough to gain the attention of the Heathers, who tentatively adopt and work toward transforming her into one of them, raising her up on the popularity scale while taking her down a rabbit hole of regret.

Meanwhile, into Veronica's life comes the new kid in town, the nihilistic if magnetically attractive loner J. D. Dean (Casey Likes, who starred on Broadway as Marty McFly in the musical Back to the Future). Romantic and sexual sparks fly, even as J. D. takes it upon himself to "protect" her from some of their more despicable classmates, leading to several sudden deaths and an even bigger scheme to rid the world of the whole kit and caboodle. Will Veronica make this a Bonnie and Clyde escapade, or will she reclaim her inherent decency?

If you are unfamiliar with the tale, I'll leave it to you to learn the rest. And I urge you to do so, because the plot unfolds in such an engaging way, and the performances by the 17-member cast are so uniformly strong, that this production of Heathers promises to be the hit of the summer and beyond.


Heathers: The Musical
On sale through January 25, 2026
New World Stages, Stage 1, 340 W 50th St.
Tickets online and current performance schedule: Telecharge.com