Past Reviews

Regional Reviews: Washington, D.C.

Damn Yankees
Arena Stage
Review by Susan Berlin | Season Schedule


Ana Villafañe and Jordan Donica
Photo by Matthew Murphy and Evan Zimmerman
Washington's Arena Stage is kicking off its 75th-anniversary season with a delightful reimagining of Damn Yankees on its Fichandler Stage. Rather than keeping the 1955 musical in its original era, playwrights Will Power and Doug Wright have adapted the original book by George Abbott and Douglass Wallop, giving it a new immediacy by moving the year up to 2000. The locale is now Baltimore rather than Washington, which did not have a major league baseball team between 1971 and 2005.

The story is still the same: die-hard fan Joe Boyd (Quentin Earl Darrington) agonizes over the dominance of the hated New York Yankees over his Orioles. He says, carelessly, that he would sell his soul to guarantee an Orioles win in the upcoming pennant race. At that moment, a smooth-talking fellow named Mr. Applegate (Rob McClure) appears and offers him a chance to do just that–and matters progress from there with the sudden arrival of phenom Joe Hardy (Jordan Donica).

Director and choreographer Sergio Trujillo has taken the spirit of Bob Fosse's legendary original choreography (which can be seen in the 1958 film version) while moving it in a new direction. The group numbers for the ballplayers are muscular but fill the in-the-round Fichandler stage with grace as well as athletic skill. Ana Villafañe's performance as Lola, sinuous and yearning by turns, has a different focus from Gwen Verdon's iconic portrayal, emphasizing that Lola may be a seductress but she retains an underlying innocence that draws her to young Joe. Donica plays Joe Hardy with a winning niceness, a lack of ego that makes him especially appealing among the rougher players on the team.

Darrington, an actor with subtlety as well as strong stage presence, brings out the character of Joe Boyd, to whom the authors have given a backstory (his father played in the Negro Leagues in the 1950s but never broke through to the majors). Bryonha Marie brings life to his wife Meg, originally written as a full-time homemaker and now a woman who has her own passion, teaching, in addition to her devotion to her marriage.

As Applegate, McClure is sly and even understated at times–he knows how to sell a line without punching it too hard, and he's a soft-shoeing charmer in "Those Were the Good Old Days." Sportswriter Gloria Thorpe, an anomalous character in the original production (a woman sportswriter?), sparkles in Alysha Umphress' sharp-edged portrayal.

Robert Brill's malleable set is bordered with video screens facing the four sides of the stage, showing still shots and some in-play video as designed by Peter Nigrini. Philip S. Rosenberg's lighting design and Walter Trarbach's sound design draw the viewer into the scene (including a sing-along moment for the audience), while Linda Cho's costumes range from Lola's glitter to the ballplayers' sensible uniforms.

Damn Yankees runs through November 9, 2025, at Arena Stage, Mead Center for American Theater, Fichandler Stage, 1101 6th St. SW, Washington DC. For tickets and information, please call 202-488-3300 or visit www.arenastage.org.

Book and lyrics by Richard Adler and Jerry Ross
Book by George Abbott and Douglass Wallop
Based on the novel The Year the Yankees Lost the Pennant by Douglass Wallop
New adaptation by Will Power and Doug Wright
Additional lyrics by Lynn Ahrens

Directed and choreographed by Sergio Trujillo
Music supervision and arrangements by Greg Anthony Rassen

Cast (in alphabetical order):
Fuzzy/Ensemble: Giuseppe Bausilio
Pena/Ensemble: Raul Contreras
Ensemble: Deanna Cudjoe
Joe Boyd: Quentin Earl Darrington
Joe Hardy: Jordan Donica
Gonzalez/Ensemble: John Michael Fiumara
Sister/Ensemble: Rayanne Gonzales
Ensemble: Danielle Marie Gonzalez
Smokey/Ensemble: Michael Harmon
Van Buren: Nehal Joshi
Ito/Ensemble: Ryo Kamibayashi
Meg Boyd: Bryonha Marie
Ensemble: Georgia Monroe
Welch: Keenan McCarter
Applegate: Rob McClure
Commissioner/Ensemble: Kevin Munhall
Sohovik/Ensemble: J Savage
Rocky/Ensemble: Justin Showell
Doris/Ensemble: Sarah Anne Sillers
Ensemble: Jordyn Taylor
Gloria Thorpe: Alysha Umphress
Lola: Ana Villafañe