Past Reviews

Regional Reviews: Phoenix

Treasure Island
Don Bluth Front Row Theatre
Review by Gil Benbrook

Also see Gil's reviews of Pretty Woman: The Musical, Six and Boeing Boeing


Christopher Sean Devous and Matthew R. Harris
Photo by Mark Gluckman
Don Bluth Front Row Theatre's production of Ken Ludwig's stage adaptation of Robert Louis Stevenson's classic novel, Treasure Island, is a lively, swashbuckling adventure that delivers exactly what audiences hope for: a fun, rollicking good time anchored by strong performances. While it takes a short while for everything to kick into gear, as soon as that lovable character Long John Silver appears, there is a sense of excitement and theatricality that carries through the production, with engaging storytelling, bursts of humor, and just the right amount of danger to keep things thrilling for audiences of all ages.

The play follows young Jim Hawkins, who discovers a mysterious treasure map that sets him on a perilous journey across the sea. Joined by a band of sailors, including Long John Silver, Jim embarks on a voyage to find buried treasure. Along the way, he must navigate shifting loyalties, hidden agendas, and the looming threat of mutiny. As the adventure unfolds, Jim grows from an eager boy into a brave and resourceful young man, learning hard lessons about trust and courage.

Ken Ludwig brings his signature wit and theatrical flair to this adaptation, streamlining Stevenson's novel into a fairly fast-paced stage show while preserving its sense of adventure. Ludwig has become well known for adapting classic literary works for the stage, including "Murder on the Orient Express," "The Three Musketeers" and a couple of plays based on Sherlock Holmes, and here he balances faithfulness to the Stevenson's novel with accessibility for modern audiences. Like the novel, the play takes a bit of time to fully set the story in motion, carefully establishing characters and stakes. However, once Long John Silver makes his entrance, the production ramps up and rarely slows down.

The performances are great. As Jim Hawkins, Christopher Sean Devous captures both the youthful enthusiasm and growing determination of the character, making his journey compelling and relatable. As Long John Silver, Matthew R. Harris is a standout, both charismatic and unpredictable. He brings charm, menace, and a hint of humor to the role, keeping the audience guessing about his true intentions while commanding the stage with ease. Silver serves as Jim's surrogate father on the ship, and Harris also plays the brief part of Jim's real father early in the play. The warmth Harris brings to the relationship makes the bond between Jim and Silver quite moving.

In a range of supporting roles, Jim "Doc" Coates, J. Clay Lawson, Jack Pauly, Jacob Shore, Brett Etzel, and Danny Forbes bring plenty of tomfoolery and danger as pirates and stiff upper lips as British citizens; Coates is especially hilarious in the second act as Ben Gunn, a pirate Jim finds on the island who is obsessed with cheese. Emily R. Sussman, Amy Searcy, Danny Forbes, Cam Oakes, and Jacob Anderson round out the cast and all appear to be having an absolute blast.

Cheryl Schaar's direction keeps the action moving briskly, ensuring that the sense of adventure, humor, and warmth in the production resonate. Aaron Blanco's fight choreography, while minimal, is well executed, with sword fights and physical confrontations that feel exciting. Schaar's set, Don Bluth's lighting, and the sound design by Schaar and Roger McKay add to the immersive quality of the production, drawing the audience into the world of pirates and treasure hunts. My only quibble is that the set changes all happen while Jim is providing narration and having several people moving about and making noise during those moments is somewhat of a distraction.

Ken Ludwig's Treasure Island at Don Bluth Front Row Theatre is an entertaining and energetic theatrical treat. With strong performances, engaging staging, and a story that continues to captivate audiences, it offers a delightful escape into a world of high seas adventure.

Treasure Island runs through April 25, 2026, at the Don Bluth Front Row Theatre, 8989 E. Vía Linda #118, Scottsdale AZ. For tickets and information, please visit www.donbluthfrontrowtheatre.com or call 480-314-0841.

Directed by Cheryl Schaar
Fight Choreographer: Aaran Blanco
Assistant Director: Brett Etzel
Scenic & Property Designer: Cheryl Schaar
Lighting Designer: Don Bluth
Sound Designer: Cheryl Schaar & Roger McKay
Costume Designer: Heather Riddle
Makeup, Hair & Wig Designer: Matthew R. Harris
Technical Director: Pete Vuyk
Stage Manager: Daniel Gottlieb
Assistant Stage Manager: Marissa JP Avery

Cast:
Jim Hawkins: Christopher Sean Devous
Long John Silver/Jim's Father: Matthew R. Harris
Dr. Livesey/Captain Flint: Jacob Shore
Squire Trelawney/Job O'Brien: Jack Pauly
Captain Smollett/Black Dog: Brett Etzel
Ben Gunn/Jemmy Rathbone: Jim "Doc" Coates
Anne Bonny/Jim's Mother: Emily R. Sussman
Justice Death/Widow Drews: Amy Searcy
Israel Hands/Blind Pew: Danny Forbes
George Merry/Bailif's Son: Cam Oakes
Tom Morgan/Ezekiel Hazard: Jacob Anderson
Billy Bones/Bristol Sailor: J. Clay Lawson